Re: action.structure:Coda

Keith R Sawyer (sawyer who-is-at cats.ucsc.edu)
Fri, 5 Apr 1996 09:38:52 -0800 (PST)

Thanks again, Mike and others, your comments have been helpful to me. I
probably am unusual in having read Marx and Weber before reading any
Soviet Psychology. I pushed this point in two successive mailings
because I think *both* perspectives are available in Vygotsky, and it's a
useful way for me to work through what his writings really offer. This
is one reason his texts have been so productive for us...

Americans are famous for being "folk action theorists," and it's manifest
not just in psychology: witness rational choice theory in economics. I'm
sure many of the participants in this list have had the frustrating
experience of trying to teach social theory texts (e.g. Durkheim, Marx)
which try to find answers in something other than individual intention
and agency; undergraduates usually have real trouble "getting it." I
just came from a class where I assigned both Ellen Winner (psychology and
the arts) and Howard Becker (Art Worlds, a sociologist) and Becker's
sociological/institutional perspective didn't really register.

Could anyone recommend a book which discusses the history/institution of
Soviet psychology, and how politics and ideology
affected/constrained/inspired it? For example, was Vygotsky suppressed
because his ideas didn't correspond to ideology?

Keith Sawyer
Department of Psychology
University of California, Santa Cruz
Santa Cruz, CA 95064