Re(2): Hair shirts, self-flagellation, and equality

Katherine Goff (Katherine_Goff who-is-at ceo.cudenver.edu)
Sun, 22 Nov 1998 09:51:05 -0700

Nate writes:
> Although, the actual message of diversity in schools of education is
>a positive one, it seems to be appropriated against a middleclass
>ideology and therefore becomes a negative difference. Everytime I am in
>a class that focuses on difference especially in reference to class and
>race I become concerned how that difference will be appropriated by most
>of the teachers. Even when there are practices that allow future
>teachers to have experiences with those who have different experiences
>than themselves (poor, minority) they leave those experiences with more
>of a sense of otherness rather than a sense of identity or commoness of
>experiences, with these other groups.
and others, like Phil, have pointed out the tension between different and
equal.
i think language is the culprit, and on many levels.

when people speak of difference, for some it becomes a practice of
objectification, of distancing and demeaning. for myself, i relish
difference. i see it as the source of energy for change and growth (mostly
within myself as i work to make meaning of the difference). i welcome the
new information, the opening up of my understanding, the view from
different perspectives.

some people speak of equality and the assumptions are based on a neutral,
universal, essentialized version of a person that represents us all. but
language supports a changeless, gendered person embodying a limited number
of attributes that leave many (most, perhaps all) individuals with
deficits as compared to this universal Man.

what about a personalized, subjective, context-dependent approach? what
about supporting teachers who each, individually, reflect on their own
practice and identity and values and motives, and think aloud some of this
confusion and ambiguity with their students? i think of belenky and her
co-researchers' conception of the midwife-teacher.
i think of donna haraways "situated knowledge."
and the journey of a thousand miles that begins with one step.
the step towards my self.

kathie

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
life's backwards,
life's backwards,
people, turn around.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^sinead o'connor and john reynolds
fire on babylon: universal mother^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Katherine_Goff who-is-at ceo.cudenver.edu
http://ceo.cudenver.edu/~katherine_goff/index.html