Re: November trains

p-prior who-is-at uiuc.edu
Wed, 17 Nov 1999 09:49:59 -0600

I see an interesting connection between your comments, Jay, on how these
synchronies/dissynchronies are patterned at N+1 and your later posting on
making new trains. I'm thinking about the way that many jobs we could take
seem to simply recruit our developmental trajectories so that, for example,
suddenly I can just be a claims adjuster in an insurance company (as I was
once for a few weeks). But (here's where making new trains come in) what
if I (and many many others) could just be a musician or a scientist or a
community organizer, what if those paths were just woven into the "normal"
fabric of development? So what processes (co-genesis of artifacts/people,
prolepsis, structuration by habitus, gatekeeping, centres of calculation
and control--structuration by enmediation, others?) might explain the
alignments/misalignments among N+1 institutional- historical-cultural
patterning, n-biographical affordances, and n-1 interactions?

>This is then part of the answer to how short bits of our lives add up to
>longer life-trajectories. It is not just that the N-1 bits do or do not
>lend themselves to level N lives, depending on whether they can synchronize
>into these longer term patterns, but also that WHICH level N life patterns
>are available are further constrained by still higher-scale N+1
>(institutional-historical-cultural) patterns. Those N+1 constraints
>(boundary conditions on self-consistent solutions at level N) do NOT
>directly control at what age or point in the school curriculum you found
>yourself too busy with other things to catch a particular career train, but
>they do constrain what career trains there are, their schedules, etc. They
>don't make your life, any more than deciding not to register for
>biochemistry this semster does. But your life is what emerges at level N
>from whether or not any possible cumulation of N-1 decisions and actions
>winds up being consistent with some N+1 pattern of the larger society.

Paul Prior
Associate Professor (English)
Associate Director, Center for Writing Studies
p-prior who-is-at uiuc.edu
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign