|
Given that I just "borrowed" that triangle for a
paper, I would certainly like to get things straight!
Phil
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, November 12, 2004 11:40
PM
Subject: Re: distribution and
exchange
Hi Yrjö,
sorry to have missed you in Helsinki. It was
interesting meeting all the students and staff. I hope you are having a good
time writing in the warmer climes of Italy.
The website with the EXCHANGE
in a different subtriangle is on the website URL: http://www.edu.helsinki.fi/activity/pages/chatanddwr/activitysystem/.
It is different from those that you had in your 1987 or 1993 (testbench)
texts.
I am very much interested in receiving a copy of the
paper.
Cheers,
Michael
On 12-Nov-04, at 8:29 AM, Yrjö
Engeström wrote:
Michael, if exchange has jumped from the S-C-Rules subtriangle
to C-O-DivLab subtriangle, it is a mistake committed by someone who made the
graphics for the web page. Please tell me where this faulty diagram is
exactly and I'll get it fixed.
As to your question, you might be
interested in a new paper in which I discuss the spheres of production,
exchange, consumption (though not distribution) - and not using the triangle
this time. The paper is titled VALUES, RUBBISH,
AND WORKPLACE LEARNING and I'll be happy to send it to you if you
want.
Cheers,
Yrjö
Wolff-Michael
Roth kirjoittaa perjantaina, 12. marraskuuta 2004, kello 16:44:
Hi,
I had some trouble with remembering where in YE's
triangle go the terms DISTRIBUTION and EXCHANGE. Today I realized for the
first time that YE used to have EXCHANGE in the S-C-RULES subtriangle but
on the website has it in the C-O-DivLab subbtriangle.
Does anyone have
an idea when this change happened and why it happened?
Has anyone
worked on the fact whether it made sense to overlay
production-consumption-exchange-distribution, which Marx discussed at the
society level onto YE's triangle, which deals with any local, concretely
realized activity?
Thanks for any
pointers.
Michael
|