Re: schooling in mean times

Ken Goodman (kgoodman who-is-at u.arizona.edu)
Thu, 15 Jul 1999 10:34:52 -0700

Mike Cole wrote:
>
> Thanks for the tips, Ken.
> We'll do our best, you can be sure.
> mike
>
> As to linearity of language. Harvey Sachs was a colleague and friend
> who wrote a lot about conversation. Ever hear him give a talk? He
> couldn't do it very well. The non-linearity of the phonemena were
> so prominent in his thinking that he had a hard time getting a sentence
> out.
>
> So, sure, you are right. But still, there are constraints on production
> and reception that make it a little difficult to say or hear everything
> at once.

Speech is linear in a temporal sense and writing is usually linear in
how it is arrayed in two dimensional space. But the comprehension of
either depends on assigning and processing semantic and syntactic
structures before they are perceived. This need to predict and infer
exists at every language level (Halliday calls them strata). In speech,
sounds vary depending on what follows them, in wording the meaning and
function of words depends on the contexts in which they are found. A
reader must know at the beginning of a sentence or utterance whether it
is a question, statement etc.

When a statement is being generated the speaker/writer starts with
meaning assigns the appropriate syntactic pattern and wording and
finally assigns the spelling or phonology. None of that is really
linear, nor is it learned in any linear sense,

Ken
> mike

-- 
Kenneth S. Goodman, Professor, Language, Reading & Culture
504 College of Education, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ     
         fax 520 7456895                      phone 520 6217868

These are mean times- and in the mean time We need to Learn to Live Under Water