Re: when is madated any different?

Linda Polin (lpolin who-is-at pepperdine.edu)
Sun, 25 Apr 1999 10:08:53 -0700

To me the whole "mandates" thing is a cultural tool that serves the
division of labor in an activity system we might call public schooling. We
often forget that schooling is first and foremost a publically funded
government endeavor to serve national socioeconomic interests. Periodically
the federales remind the states of that, and periodically the state
legislatures(esp'ly in California) remind those of us involved in schooling
as a profession.

What I find fascinating is that so many private schools don't move very far
afield from the curriculum and methods of the publics. As we all know, they
succeed because they admit kids who will succeed. They educate about as
much as I bake when I make a cake from a box mix.

I think it is highly significant that powerful stories of successful
learning situations, some of the 5th Dimension projects, for example, are
found outside the formal K-12 schooling activity.

I may be digressing a bit here but, my favorite counter example (heck, my
only one) of local control in curriculum is Steven Levy's (see his new
book: Starting from Scratch, from Heineman). The kids(4th or 5th grade I
think) entered an empty classroom in the Fall and literally built their own
desks and, what a surprise, found themeslves accomplishing a sophisticated
curriculum. (It's sort of Waldorf-ian).

imho,
Linda