Re: individual and society

Phillip Allen White (pwhite who-is-at carbon.cudenver.edu)
Mon, 18 Sep 1995 14:33:01 -0600 (MDT)

Mike, I think your last message (quote) re: the child making sense of the
society into which it has been born, coupled with Jay's earlier remarks
about the constructs of school curriculum with the attendant conflicts
over specific content viewed through a political lens, and Peter's
comments about Cartesian thought prevalent in American schools - whew! -
all of this has caused me to wonder how the following curriculum
objective can possibly be explained.

In my school district we are following the state of Colorado's initiative
in writing performance standards - (Local 'Babbits' claim that this is to
place Colorado in the 'forefront' of 'education' for the '21st century'.)

Example: Grade 2 - The student knows and is able to: Describe
how democratic ideas and institutions in the U.S.have developed, changed,
and / or been maintained. Indicators of Performance: Explains the
meaning of the Pledge of Allegiance. Continuum: Understands the meaning
of the Pledge of Allegiance.
Students know that religious and philosophical ideas have been
powerful forces throughout history. The student knows and is able to:
Explain the origins and historical development of religions and
philosophical beliefs. Indicators of Performance: Explains the meaning
of the Pledge of Allegiance. Continuum: Recites the Pledge of Allegiance
and recognizes it as a statement of our country's foundation.

I can't imagine what a child in the second grade (seven to eight
years old) could possibly make of this.

Phillip