[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [xmca] From NYTimes: Brazil?s Leftist Ruling Party, Born of Protests, Is Perplexed by Revolt

Sent via my BlackBerry from Vodacom - let your email find you!

-----Original Message-----
From: Brecht De Smet <Brechttie.DeSmet@UGent.be>
Sender: xmca-bounces@weber.ucsd.edu
Date: Sun, 23 Jun 2013 08:08:11 
To: <ablunden@mira.net>; eXtended Mind, Culture, Activity<xmca@weber.ucsd.edu>
Reply-To: "eXtended Mind, Culture, Activity" <xmca@weber.ucsd.edu>
Subject: Re: [xmca] From NYTimes: Brazil?s Leftist Ruling Party, Born of
	Protests, Is Perplexed by Revolt

Did I hear my name?

    Here you can find a draft chapter for Andy's upcoming book on
Projects: http://www.academia.edu/3715686/Tahrir_a_Project_ion_of_Revolutionary_Change

    I[1]t deals with the dynamics of Tahrir as a revolutionary movement
and, among other things, the concept of revolution as a developmental
process with histories and potentialities, against both
optimist-maximalist and dismissive-minimalist "definitions". 


Dr. Brecht De Smet
    Assistant Professor at the Department of Conflict and Development Studies
    Researcher at MENARG (Middle East and North Africa Research Group)
    Faculty of Political and Social Sciences
    Ghent University
    Universiteitsstraat 8 / 9000 Gent / Belgium
    Tel: +32496784370

Quoting Andy Blunden <ablunden@mira.net>:
> Andre, you should check out the work of Brecht de Smet, who has used  
> the Project approach to Activity Theory to study the Egyptian  
> Revolution. He uses Marx, Granmsci and Vygotsky as well as a great  
> amount of "field work".
>   Andy
>   André Machado Rodrigues wrote:  > Hi Mike and David,
>>    Maybe this piece written by Michalis adds more about Brazilian political
>>    mood in 2010.
>> http://landlessmov2010.wordpress.com/background/novelas-and-football/
>>    If dialectics deals with the born, development and death of the object.
>>    Perhaps I have the chance to trace it here. (???)
>>    I highlight a short part:
>>    The evening comes. I am quite tired and want to retreat to the  
>> room where I
>>    sleep, but remain for a moment in a space that could be called  
>> the ?living
>>    room,? where the whole family sits ? not on but in front of ?  
>> the sofa, so
>>    that their backs are against the sofa and their legs stretched  
>> out in front
>>    of them. There is a football match, and everybody ? including the female
>>    family members and children ? watch with enthusiasm. I have never been a
>>    fan of watching TV, not movies, matches, soap operas, or game shows.
>>    However, the scene is quite interesting for my ethnography[...]
>>    At most of the Landless Workers? settlements where I was, no one spoke
>>    about the global economic crisis or Brazilian economic policies, open
>>    questions about organic farming were very little discussed, and  
>> there were
>>    no reading groups to discuss newspaper articles, classic political
>>    economical analyses, or reports by other organic producers  
>> elsewhere in the
>>    world. Somehow the interest was not there, and a feeling  
>> dominated that it
>>    was not necessary because a lot had already been achieved. People did not
>>    discuss their dependence on money and technologies that they could not
>>    produce on their own, or about the future of the movement. Even the
>>    settlement itself was organized so that public space was limited.
>>    BR, André
>>    Date: Thu, 20 Jun 2013 22:08:03 -0400
>>    From: David Preiss <daviddpreiss@gmail.com>
>>    Subject: Re: [xmca] From NYTimes: Brazil?s Leftist Ruling Party, Born
>>           of Protests, Is Perplexed by Revolt
>>    To: lchcmike@gmail.com
>>    Cc: "eXtended Mind, Culture, Activity" <xmca@weber.ucsd.edu>
>>    Message-ID: <9E6B2090-D9B5-4998-AEB0-B60A1067D4DA@gmail.com>
>>    Content-Type: text/plain;       charset=windows-1252
>>    Same things happening here as well: universities have evolved from being
>>    ivory tower institutions to become job training institutes without ever
>>    being settled in their calling to become laboratories of  
>> critical thinking.
>>    One of the things that I find most conservative of the new generations is
>>    that many of their demands are quite sensitive to the demands of the job
>>    market however their nature. Prepare us for real jobs, give us the
>>    practical skills to succeed "out there".  What about intellectual
>>    discovery? I love the image of Charles Darwin boarding the Beagle
>>    expedition when he had the age of a contemporary young graduate student.
>>    And I usually tell my students to contrast their boring and safe learning
>>    experience with that of Darwin.
>>    On the other hand, if we look at the "grown ups" side, given the demands
>>    that the faculty face these days, I assume that many professors  
>> -specially
>>    the younger ones- are not in a situation to make risky adventures on
>>    unchartered paths of thought and board their own Beagles. These days, the
>>    nature of the academic job at the university has to do more with the
>>    industrial production of knowledge than with the free  
>> exploration of ideas.
>>    If an academic needs a good h-index to secure his or her post he or she
>>    should not be waiting time in publishing papers that go to  
>> anything that is
>>    not the mainstream.
>>    Meanwhile, we are in a situation where the words "innovation" &
>>    "globalization" have such societal valued attached that many universities
>>    will become technological factories. Specially, with the universities
>>    worldwide confronting many financial challenges which can be sorted out
>>    with university entrepreneurship. The humanities are feeling the  
>> stress of
>>    this evolving dynamic and the social sciences are becoming everyday less
>>    "social" whatever that words means. That this is happening in a context
>>    where the human species is facing quite dramatic ecological and societal
>>    crisis makes the situation quite problematic.
>>    On Jun 20, 2013, at 9:11 PM, mike cole wrote:
>>> Many thoughts on your summary of the situation from where you live and
>>    work,
>>> David.
>>>     Here my most vivid impression after a year of teaching a "theory and
>>    practice" course with more or less the same students..... a  
>> whole academic
>>    year. It was a
>>> great experience, but there is a huge gap between student expectations
>>    and faculty
>>> concerns. The students are terrified of the future. They see a long haul
>>    from barista to barrister, or whatever their aims are.
>>> They have learned, "mastered" in Jim Wertsch's sense, the melange of
>>    theories that faculty use to analyse various forms of communication,
>>    broadly construed. The faculty is in fashion these days in the range of
>>    fields it draws upon. A lot of critical
>>> theory.
>>>     They want jobs. Event planning, marketing, pr, advertising....... you
>>    know, the kind of stuff a university SHOULD be teaching.("Why,  
>> look at San
>>    Diego State down the road! They do a much better job of preparing us for
>>    our futures than you do.")
>>> As professionals when it came down to actually planning the real event
>>    these students were, by and large, pros. And what didn't know,  
>> they had the
>>    good sense to learn during this class: web skills, filming and editing
>>    skills, blogging skills, all of which, they knew or believed  
>> they new, were
>>    actually instrumental to shining at THE EVENT.
>>> But linking events of the sort that people go to a lot of trouble of
>>    planning, to any general principles of communication? Naw, that's not
>>    possible! Makes for interesting teaching. I learned a lot. A syllabus on
>>    "eventology" has been put together by
>>> the class to present to the faculty.
>>>     So what? I cannot save them from their futures. I can try to  
>>> prepare them
>>    for
>>> their futures, but they know a lot more about it than I do? Or a lot
>>    differently.
>>> The value of democracy? From what I see around me, democracy rides on the
>>    back of either a full stomach, or at least the promise of a  
>> fuller stomach.
>>    But if it comes down to one-person-vs one vote on the one hand,  
>> and a full
>>    enough stomach on the other. people seem to be able to stomach some very
>>    difficult forms of life.
>>> The solution? Quien sabe?
>>>     mike
>>>     On Thu, Jun 20, 2013 at 5:53 PM, David Preiss <daviddpreiss@gmail.com>
>>    wrote:
>>> Chile has been experiencing the same level of unrest for several years.
>>    Interestingly the focus of protests here is on the inequalities of our
>>    educational system, which express the ominous inequalities of Chilean
>>    society. The "student movement" has thus galvanized a broad demand for
>>    social justice, although some of their demands may have consequences that
>>    would not necessarily foster social justice if applied as  
>> requested without
>>    adding other structural reforms. The more contentious issue is whether
>>    university education should be free for all. As the universities here
>>    recruit most of their students among the socio-ecomomically advantaged,
>>    free public education at the university level will give more  
>> money to those
>>    that have more resources. In a country where the majority of poor kids
>>    don't have access to a good pre-school education many people think we
>>    should address preschool education first.
>>> My main concern is how this social unrest can be channeled in a way that
>>    strengthens democracy. So far, our politicians have been incapable to
>>    provide an adequate interpretation to what is going on. And to  
>> the lack of
>>    communication between politicians and the public we can add that  
>> there is a
>>    generational struggle going on between the generations that were educated
>>    in a recovered democracy and the older ones that had to go  
>> through the ugly
>>    business of reconquering it by means of negotiation and not violence.
>>    Unfortunately, many of the protests have provided the occasion to violent
>>    clashes between protesters and the police as we are seeing in Turkey and
>>    Brazil. And students have adopted strategies that some people may share,
>>    and some others not: e.g., occupying schools, universities, stopping
>>    classes, and so. On the other hand, some student leaders are not
>>    necessarily "dialogical" (neither is the government). So, we have been in
>>    an impasse for almost half decade.
>>> There is a lot at stake here. Not only whether people would pay or not
>>    according to their means for a public funded university  
>> education but also
>>    the way disagreements are and will be solved within Chilean  
>> democracy. Are
>>    our institutions solid enough to provide a good solution to  
>> civil unrest or
>>    would the country enter a stage of increasing polarization that  
>> would take
>>    the issue to a different arena where those with more power will end up
>>    imposing their views?
>>> On Jun 20, 2013, at 4:04 PM, mike cole wrote:
>>>> Here is what a leading American newspaper is telling its readers about
>>>>      Brazil today, for those outside of Brazil who have not been following
>>>>      events.
>>>>      mike
>>>>> Brazil?s Leftist Ruling Party, Born of Protests, Is Perplexed by
>>>>>       Revolt
>>>>>       <
>> http://p.nytimes.com/email/re?location=InCMR7g4BCKC2wiZPkcVUhzORrBwHzZn&user_id=bd31502e6eb851a9261827fdfbbcdf6d&email_type=eta&task_id=137175838146698>
>>    By
>>>>>       The governing Workers Party is watching with dismay as  
>>>>> Brazil?s largest
>>>>>       city braces for a new round of demonstrations on Thursday.
>>>>>         Or, copy and paste this URL into your browser:
>> http://nyti.ms/16jagoV
>>>>> <
>> http://p.nytimes.com/email/re?location=InCMR7g4BCKC2wiZPkcVUhzORrBwHzZn&user_id=bd31502e6eb851a9261827fdfbbcdf6d&email_type=eta&task_id=137175838146698>
>>      To
>>>>> ensure delivery to your inbox, please add nytdirect@nytimes.com to your
>>>>>       address book.  Advertisement
>>>>>       <
>>>>> Copyright 2013<[3]
>> http://p.nytimes.com/email/re?location=4z5Q7LhI+KVBjmEgFdYACMlEhIhWVuPIxganfKahJGpDcKtdpfztygRnz23j1z6nDpx4eAAqQbYRMMl5L56EeQ==&user_id=bd31502e6eb851a9261827fdfbbcdf6d&email_type=eta&task_id=137175838146698
>>>>> | The New York Times Company<[4]
>> http://p.nytimes.com/email/re?location=4z5Q7LhI+KUv6vqdu/zT/DtUzLlQEcSh&user_id=bd31502e6eb851a9261827fdfbbcdf6d&email_type=eta&task_id=137175838146698
>>>>> | NYTimes.com 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018
>>>>>        [5]
>>>> ______________________________[5]
>> ____________[5]
>>>> _____
>>>>      xmca mailing list[5]
>>>> xmca@weber.ucsd.edu
>>>> http://dss.ucsd.edu/mailman/listinfo/xmca
> --
>   ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>   *Andy Blunden*
>   Home Page:[6]http://home.mira.net/~andy/
>   Book:[7]http://www.brill.nl/concepts
> http://marxists.academia.edu/AndyBlunden
>   __________________________________________
>   _____
>   xmca mailing list[8]
> xmca@weber.ucsd.[9]eduhttp://dss.ucsd.edu/mailman/listinfo/xmca

[2] http://www.psw.ugent.be/menarg
[6] http://dss.ucsd.edu/mailman/listinfo/xmca
[7] http://home.mira.net/~andy/
[8] http://marxists.academia.edu/AndyBlunden
[9] mailto:xmca@weber.ucsd
xmca mailing list
xmca mailing list