[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[xmca] synchronic contexts & play

Hi Mike and Andy

I was just re-reading the article you and Natalia wrote in the edited book
"The Sociocultural Turn in Psychology" The title was "Vygotsky and Context:
Towards a Theoretical Resolution"  I wanted to return to this article after
reading Andy's 2 articles posted, - on the historical development of the
concept "Gestalt" and his article on the concept of activity.

 [I would recommend others read these three articles together]

Mike, you and Natalia referenced a study by Nielsen and Dissanayake which
shows that young children can hold and act upon a false belief in their PEER
PLAY but could not act upon the false belief when participating in a
standard false belief task.  Their cognitive abilities in play were more
advanced.  My question is if Andy's notion of a COLLABORATIVE project [for
these children a play context] can give an explanation of this phenomena.
Also I want  to link the centrality of syncronic contexts with my musings on
2nd person and 3rd person perspectives.
Is it possible that standard false belief tasks require a 3rd person stance
on the task whereas the play setting supports 2nd person perspectives [which
are "shared mind" contexts that are fundamentally intersubjective].  If this
is possible then synchronic zpd's  that developmentally "hold" shared mind
co-constructions [2nd person contexts] PRECEDE the development of 3rd person
objective spectator false beliefs and 1st person experiences of false

xmca mailing list