RE: Is there something wrong with this story? What or who is missing?

From: Ben Kirshner (kirshner@stanford.edu)
Date: Mon Feb 17 2003 - 08:47:18 PST


At risk of seeming optimistic, I am noticing a slight shift in the way the
print media is handling these protests, especially in contrast to those
held in October. Whereas the protests didn't merit an article from the
Sunday NY Times in October, yesterday they got quite a bit of
attention. And today's front page of SF Chronicle, in bold print: "Huge,
peaceful crowd protests stance in Iraq: At SF Rally, 200,000 seek
alternative to US War."

Of course, this may not be the case in other cities in the US. And I don't
have CNN or other cable news channels, so I don't know how it plays there.

It's not so much that mainstream media institutions have suddenly taken up
a critical position, but that these global protests are an un-deniable
story. (Too bad American media didn't feel that way about the World Social
Forum in Brazil, which received almost no coverage, it seemed).

Ben

At 11:49 AM 2/17/2003 +0000, you wrote:
>Just to say, I was on the march in London. Certainly the biggest of my
>long demo-going career. Police always underestimate by 30-40% so I reckon
>it was at least a million. It took me 4-5 hours for a route that normally
>takes 1 1/2 and there was a continuous stream all afternoon going in to
>the rally.
>
>I went with a contingent under the slogan 'No to war! No to Saddam' - it
>is important not to forget the Iraqi people's interest in getting rid of
>Saddam, but also not to put any trust in the oil-grabbers introducing
>anything approximating to a democracy in Iraq - in yesterday's Observer
>even one of the 'official' (US backed)Iraqi opposition made the point that
>on the day 'after liberation' they expect to come into conflict with the
>US over what form of government will be imposed in Iraq after Saddam.
>
>Along these lines, an international declaration 'No to war! No to Saddam!
>For democracy and international solidarity!' can be found at
>http://homepage.powerup.com.au/~martin/ . It originated in the US and has
>been signed by Chomsky, Said and others.
>
>Bruce R
>
> > from: Ana Marjanovic-Shane <anamshane@speakeasy.net>
> > date: Sat, 15 Feb 2003 21:33:01
> > to: xmca@weber.ucsd.edu, vygotsky@charter.net
> > subject: RE: Is there something wrong with this story? What or who is
> missing?
> >
> > I just came home form the Peace March in Philadelphia. The police estimate
> > of the numbers is about 10,000 people. I was in a crowd myself and have no
> > idea how many were there -- it seemed huge to me. The march went from Broad
> > and Spring Garden toward City Hall, passing the "Philadelphia Inquirer"
> > building, going to the Marines Recruiting Center and finally to the Liberty
> > Bell.
> > People carried all kinds of signs, many home made. A group of people had
> > made huge signs in the shape of oil drilling towers. They had the following
> > words inscribed over these signs: "Read between the pipelines". Many people
> > carried "Not in my name" signs. One hand written sign spelled out: "33
> > million below the poverty line, but $200 million for war??" The juiciest
> > slogan was "Bombing for peace is like f**ing for virginity."
> > There were people of all ages, races, genders... Even in a crowd of 10,000
> > one finds a lot of known faces and friends.
> > All of this took place while the temperature was 26 degrees (Fahrenheit),
> > or -3 degrees (Celsius).
> >
> > The question is -- are these protests by millions of voices around the
> world
> > going to be heard by the powers? Can they be ignored? Can they make a
> > difference?
> >
> > Ana
> >
> >
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: N [mailto:vygotsky@charter.net]
> > Sent: Saturday, February 15, 2003 12:17 PM
> > To: xmca@weber.ucsd.edu
> > Subject: Is there something wrong with this story? What or who is
> > missing?
> >
> >
> > Top Stories - AP
> > Thousands Worldwide Protest War in Iraq
> > 42 minutes ago
> > Add Top Stories - AP to My Yahoo!
> >
> > By ROBERT BARR, Associated Press Writer
> >
> > LONDON - Anti-war protests Saturday drew hundreds of thousands of people
> > in cities around the world from London to Canberra united in their
> > opposition to a threatened U.S.-led strike against Iraq.
> >
> > Photo
> > AP Photo
> >
> > AP Photo Photo
> > AP Photo
> > Slideshow Slideshow: Iraq War Protests
> >
> >
> > Special Coverage
> > Latest news:
> > " Thousands in Iraq March to Support Saddam
> > AP - 1 hour, 17 minutes ago
> > " U.S. Planes Hit Iraq Missile Sites
> > AP - 1 hour, 23 minutes ago
> > " U.S. Fails to Rally U.N. Support on Iraq
> > AP - Sat Feb 15, 8:20 AM ET
> > Special Coverage
> >
> >
> >
> > The British capital saw one of the largest marches for peace on a day of
> > global protest at least a million people, organizers claimed, although
> > initial police estimates were about half that. They hoped to heap
> > pressure on Prime Minister Tony Blair (news - web sites), who has been
> > Europe's biggest supporter of the tough U.S. policy.
> >
> > "I feel they should take more time and find an alternative, and not see
> > the only solution to the problem in bombarding the country," said Maria
> > Harvey, 58, a child psychologist, who said she hadn't marched since the
> > protests against the Gulf War (news - web sites) in 1991.
> >
> > There was another huge turnout in Rome, where many in the crowd
> > displayed rainbow "peace" flags. Police offered no estimate, but
> > organizers claimed 3 million people participated.
> >
> > Hundreds of thousands marched through Berlin, backing a strong anti-war
> > stance spearheaded by Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder. Police estimated the
> > crowd at between 300,000 and 500,000.
> >
> > "We're not taking to the streets to demonstrate against the United
> > States, or for Iraq. We're taking to the streets because we want a
> > peaceful resolution of the Iraq conflict," said Michael Sommer, head of
> > the German Federation of Unions.
> >
> > In Syria, a nation on the front line if war comes, some 200,000
> > protesters marched through Damascus. In Bulgaria, Hungary, South Korea
> > (news - web sites), Australia, Malaysia and Thailand, demonstrations
> > attracted thousands, while the crowds were in the hundreds or less in
> > Romania, Bosnia, Hong Kong, Indian-controlled Kashmir (news - web sites)
> > and Moscow.
> >
> > Police estimated that 60,000 turned out in Oslo, Norway, 50,000 in
> > bitter cold in Brussels, while about 35,000 gathered peacefully in
> > frigid Stockholm.
> >
> > Crowds were estimated at 10,000 in Amsterdam and Copenhagen, 5,000 in
> > Capetown and 4,000 in Johannesburg in South Africa, 5,000 in Tokyo,
> > 3,000 in Vienna and 2,000 in Dhaka, Bangladesh.
> >
> > "War is not a solution, war is a problem," Czech philosopher Erazim
> > Kohak told a crowd of about 500 in Prague.
> >
> > Anti-war activists hoped to draw 100,000 people to the streets in New
> > York City later for a protest near the United Nations (news - web
> > sites). Police were planning extensive security that included
> > sharpshooters and radiation detectors.
> >
> > In Baghdad, tens of thousands of Iraqis, many carrying Kalashnikovs,
> > demonstrated across their country to support Saddam Hussein (news - web
> > sites) and denounce the United States.
> >
> > "Our swords are out of their sheaths, ready for battle," read one of
> > hundreds of banners carried by marchers along Palestine Street, a broad
> > Baghdad avenue.
> >
> > Many Iraqis hoisted giant pictures of Saddam and some burned American
> > and Israeli flags, while in neighboring Damascus, protesters chanted
> > anti-U.S. and anti-Israeli slogans as they marched to the People's
> Assembly.
> >
> > Najjah Attar, a former Syrian cabinet minister, accused Washington of
> > attempting to change the region's map. "The U.S. wants to encroach upon
> > our own norms, concepts and principles," she said in Damascus. "They are
> > reminding us of the Nazi and fascist times."
> >
> > Braving biting cold and snow flurries in Ukraine, some 2,000 people
> > rallied in Kiev's central square. Anti-globalists led a peaceful "Rock
> > Against War" protest joined by communists, socialists, Kurds and pacifists.
> >
> > Natalya Mostenko, 45, was one of several people in Kiev carrying a
> > portrait of Saddam. "He opposes American dictatorship and so do I," she
> > said.
> >
> >
> >
> > In the Bosnian city of Mostar, about a hundred Muslims and Croats united
> > for an anti-war protest the first such cross-community action in seven
> > years in a place where ethnic divisions here remain tense despite the
> > 1995 Bosnian peace agreement.
> >
> > "We want to say that war is evil and that we who survived one know that
> > better than anyone," said Majda Hadzic, 54.
> >
> > In divided Cyprus, about 500 Greeks and Turks braved heavy rain for a
> > march which briefly blocked the end of a runway at a British air base.
> >
> > Several thousand protesters in Athens, Greece, unfurled a giant banner
> > across the wall of the ancient Acropolis "NATO (news - web sites),
> > U.S. and EU equals War" before heading toward the U.S. Embassy.
> >
> > Police fired tear gas in clashes with several hundred anarchists wearing
> > hoods and crash helmets, who broke from the otherwise peaceful march to
> > smash store windows and throw a gasoline bomb at a newspaper office.
> >
> > In the Greek port of Thessaloniki, an estimated 10,000 people protested.
> >
> > About 2,000 demonstrators rallied in Sofia, the Bulgarian capital. In
> > Moscow, 300 people marched to the U.S. Embassy, with one placard urging
> > Russian President Vladimir Putin (news - web sites) to "be firmer with
> > America."
> >
> > Six hundred people rallied in downtown Hong Kong, as did 50 or so in
> > Almaty, Kazakhstan.
> >
> > Police in Srinagar in Indian-controlled Kashmir detained at least 35
> > protesters after about a hundred people, mostly supporters of the
> > Communist Party of India (Marxist), marched through the city.
> >
> > Demonstrators clogged a downtown park in Seoul, South Korea, to chant
> > and listen to anti-war speeches.
> >
> > "I am scared, but the Iraqi people must be more scared than I am. I
> > share their fear," said Eun Kook, a 23-year-old student planning to go
> > to Iraq. "My mission is to sympathize with the Iraqi people and to tell
> > the world that we oppose war."
> >
> > The day of protest began in New Zealand, where thousands gathered in
> > cities across the country. Over Auckland harbor, a plane trailed a
> > banner reading "No War Peace Now," at the America's Cup sailing
> > competition.
> >
> > Between 3,000 and 5,000 people marched through a suburb of Canberra, the
> > Australian capital, to protest government support for U.S. policy.
> > Australia has already committed 2,000 troops to the Persian Gulf for
> > possible action.
> >
> > In Tokyo, where 6,000 protested on Friday, about 300 activists gathered
> > near the U.S. Embassy. One placard depicted a U.S. flag emblazoned with
> > a swastika.
> >
> > Demonstrators in Asia expressed skepticism that Iraq posed a threat to
> > world security, saying that President Bush (news - web sites) was
> > seeking to extend American control over oil reserves.
> >
> > "We must stop the war as it is part of the United States' plot for
> > global domination," protest organizer Nasir Hashim told 1,500 cheering
> > activists outside the U.S. Embassy in the Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpur.
> > --
> > There is no hope of finding the sources of free action in the lofty
> > realms of the mind or in the depths of the brain. The idealist approach
> > of the phenomenologists is as hopeless as the positive approach of the
> > naturalists. To discover the sources of free action it is necessary to
> > go outside the limits of the organism, not into the intimate sphere of
> > the mind, but into the objective forms of social life; it is necessary
> > to seek the sources of human consciousness and freedom in the social
> > history of humanity. To find the soul it is necessary to lose it".
> > A.R Luria
> >
> > Nate
> > vygotsky@charter.net
> > http://webpages.charter.net/schmolze1/
> >
> >



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sat Mar 01 2003 - 01:00:06 PST