-----Original Message-----
From: Peter Smagorinsky [mailto:smago@peachnet.campuscwix.net]
Sent: Thursday, April 06, 2000 4:54 AM
To: xmca@ucsd.edu
Subject: Re: April Discussion Paper
Helena, thanks for your kind words.
You're right, I wouldn't call it a model--as our xmca discussion always
reinforces to me, there's too much uncertainty for the notion of a static
model to apply. The paper, like all efforts at meaning, is a provisional
effort to explore the topic.
Peter
At 11:17 PM 4/5/00 -0500, you wrote:
I'd like to say a few words about Peter's paper. I enjoyed it more than I
have
ever enjoyed anything on the subject of how people read. You could have
called
it, "The Physics of Meaning." His description of how meaning is produced
through the construction of a new text by a reader has the patient pace and
lucidity of a scientific explanation of how a rainbow is produced by the
refraction of light through a prism.
Two assumptions made me happy: One, that signs are most often verbal, but
may
also be images, dance forms, music, etc. The other that "the richest
meanings
come through transactions that are most generative in the production of
potent
new texts."
After some years of teaching literature and drama I found myself more
interested in the mystery of the reader than the mystery of the text. Peter
captures the mystery of the readers as I know them. The readers I teach are
a
collective subject -- union representatives, stewards, learning how to
manage
the cycles of texts that are part of the work of representation. Peter's
description is plausible whether one is thinking of school kids reading
Hamlet
or a shop steward studying his contract, preparing for a bargaining session
(the production of a new text). Plausibility is a good thing in a model.
Peter, would you want this called a model? Probably not, I'd guess.
Helena Worthen
Assistant Professor of Labor Education
Chicago Labor Education Program
Institute of Labor and Industrial Relations
815 West Van Buren Street Suite 214
Chicago, IL 60607
hworthen@uic.edu
hworthen@igc.org
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue May 23 2000 - 09:21:13 PDT